on November 6th, 2023

In architecture and construction, even the tiniest miscalculation can result in monumental catastrophes. Join us as we explore five of the costliest civil and construction engineering mishaps worldwide.

Mistakes happen to the best of us, and often, they come with valuable lessons. But what if these errors cost billions of dollars or, even worse, put lives at risk?

Even the most spectacular designs can crumble under the weight of costly mistakes in engineering and construction. These five examples are potent reminders that attention to detail, rigorous planning, and adherence to best practices are indispensable in preventing engineering mishaps of epic proportions.

As we continue to push the boundaries of what is possible in architecture and construction, these cautionary tales should be etched into our collective memory to ensure a safer, more soundly built future.

The Sydney Opera House: Costly Engineering Overture

The Sydney Opera House: Costly Engineering Overture

The iconic Sydney Opera House, admired worldwide, conceals a turbulent history of planning and construction beneath its elegant sails. Due to its complex slated arches, it was initially slated for a four-year completion with a budget of AU $7 million. Still, this masterpiece stretched its timeline to 14 years and a total cost of AU $14 million. To make matters worse, acoustical errors plagued the venue, rendering it a place where musicians couldn’t even hear their own music.

The Opera House’s most significant blunder was a switch in the placement of the opera house and stage production halls, resulting in an additional expense of nearly AU $300 million to rectify the acoustics.

Seongsu Bridge Collapse: A Tragic Oversight

In 1994, Seoul’s Seongsu Bridge witnessed a horrific disaster when its central section crumbled into the Han River, claiming the lives of 31 individuals. Designed to handle a load of 36.3 tonnes per car, the bridge frequently carried vehicles exceeding 47.3 tonnes.

Post-investigation, an engineering flaw in certain joints was discovered, costing the state council US $185,000 (almost AU $294,000) in compensation for the lives lost and US $2 million (almost AU $3.2 million) for repairs.

Subsequent findings revealed lapses in repair and scheduled maintenance, making the Seongsu Bridge collapse a tragedy exacerbated by negligence.

Tacoma Narrows Bridge: A Costly Gust of Wind

Spanning the Tacoma Narrows strait in Washington, USA, the twin suspension bridge was a marvel of its time when constructed in 1940. With an estimated cost of $6 million (AU $9.5 million), equivalent to $1 billion (almost AU $1.6 billion) today with inflation, this bridge had a disappointingly short lifespan of only four months and seven days.

Engineering flaws caused the bridge to sway alarmingly in the wind, even during normal conditions. The bridge’s ultimate downfall occurred on a day with winds reaching a speed of about 19m/s, leading to a collapse attributed to “aeroelastic flutter.” Miraculously, no lives were lost in the incident, but this engineering mishap gave rise to a new theory in construction: wind theory oscillations.

The Walkie-Talkie: A Blinding Glare

In London, 20 Fenchurch Street, affectionately nicknamed “The Walkie Talkie” for its unique shape, was completed in 2014 at a cost exceeding £200 million (over AU $380 million).

However, this expensive skyscraper revealed itself to be an extravagant architectural error. The building’s glass facade and curvature acted as an enormous concave mirror, reflecting sunlight onto the street for about two hours daily.

The intense heat, reaching approximately 72℃, resulted in cracked tiles, charred carpets, melting paint, and even scorched cars. The building quickly earned a new moniker, “The Walkie Scorchie.”

Remedying this architectural misstep involved the installation of a sunscreen across its curved face at an additional cost of approximately £10 million (over AU $19 million).

Leaning Tower of Pisa

Last but certainly not least is the world-famous Leaning Tower of Pisa. Despite its peculiar tilt, this Italian landmark has captured the hearts of many. The reason for its lean is simple: the construction site’s soil was too soft to support such a massive structure, causing the tower’s foundations to be unstable.

Engineering Burner: London’s Walkie-Talkie Building

Historians argue that the builders realized the tower would lean when they reached the third story but continued construction regardless. In a fun twist, the tower doesn’t merely lean; it’s slowly falling. Since 1178, it has been descending at one to two millimeters yearly.

Remarkably, unlike the other construction blunders on this list, the Leaning Tower of Pisa didn’t incur additional costs. Instead, it has become a lucrative attraction, drawing countless tourists worldwide.

References

Lessons from the Opera House fiasco

Billion-Dollar Construction Mistakes

7 of the Most Costly Mistakes of Architectural Design

The latest news

EIT News

A Hero with a Lifesaving Legacy  

Meet James Mackay, the Technology Manager at the Engineering Institute of Technology (EIT), also known as a hero. His journey is nothing short of inspiring, and it's about time the... Read more
EIT News

UAE Floods: Role of Engineers in Cloud Seeding and Climate

The recent downpour in Dubai has raised the question of whether cloud seeding or extreme weather was to blame and what engineering is involved in either scenario. The recent downpour... Read more
EIT News

3D Printing: Technology, Applications, and Future Prospects 

In this insightful blog, we investigate the transformative field of additive manufacturing.   The Engineering Institute of Technology’s (EIT) senior Mechanical Engineering on-campus lecturer and the Doctor of Engineering Research Coordinator, Dr. Vishal... Read more
Engineering Institute of Technology